ModNation Racers or Skate3 ??

This topic is empty.

Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)

Author

Posts
June 11, 2010 at 5:20 pm #15647

MaDDoGG87
Member

i cant decide what to buy MNR or Skate3 ?? please help !!

June 11, 2010 at 6:10 pm #62517

dizzel22
Member

Dont have skate 3 but MNR is loads of fun

June 11, 2010 at 6:18 pm #62518

I773D33MABL3
Member

Buy MNR and download all my stuff!!!

June 11, 2010 at 7:14 pm #62523

Doc-B
Member

Create a new user profile on your Ps3 to use for when your trying games out; so you don't load unwanted trophy lists onto your own profile.Then rent them both and have a proper play.

The games are so diff. it's difficult to choose… In what aspect are you speaking about? Playability, online, creativity, longevity, replayability, styling, skill set, etc.

Overall? I ain't played Skate 3 to judge…

And i find the track creation in MNR gets my attention than the SP, I've only done a handful of races (It's not as good as Mario Kart) and i LOVE building tracks… But learning all the tricks in Skate and pulling off some crazy combos is always rewarding…

Trying them both is a “fail safe” method of choosing… And logical

June 11, 2010 at 9:06 pm #62527

MaDDoGG87
Member

yer i reckon i’ll jus rent both at some point but MNR is grabbing me more well thanks for your views i’ll let every1 know what i get

June 11, 2010 at 9:40 pm #62529

parnakas
Member

MNR is a lot of fun, and if you just want to play skate strictly for gameplay, you can pick up Skate 2 for really cheap, which is essentially the same game as Skate 3 (Sorry to piss anyone off, but come on..).

June 12, 2010 at 12:40 am #62534

Miiiitch
Member

I own both and while they both have there flaws Skate 3 is the much better game of the 2, MNR has the most ridiculous loading times I have ever seen (LBP never had this problem and there essentially the same game except LBP was platforming), the gameplay of MNR is not that smooth (especially online) and the online itself is a complete wreck. In the end it's up to you and they are both enjoyable games but Skate 3 is definently better.

Edit: also skate 2 is not the same as skate 3, this is coming from someone who has played all 3.

June 12, 2010 at 4:31 pm #62549

MaDDoGG87
Member

Well i have decided to buy MNR as i have skate2 & im only 6 trophys away from the platinum but i have to start from scratch on the story because i lost my data awhile back

EDiT- but i will get Skate3 when im done with skate2 because i do love the skate series thank for your help

June 14, 2010 at 6:44 am #62579

TomTom12992
Member

Miiiitch said:

Post edited 10:49 pm – 06/11/2010 by Miiiitch

I own both and while they both have there flaws Skate 3 is the much better game of the 2, MNR has the most ridiculous loading times I have ever seen (LBP never had this problem and there essentially the same game except LBP was platforming), the gameplay of MNR is not that smooth (especially online) and the online itself is a complete wreck. In the end it’s up to you and they are both enjoyable games but Skate 3 is definently better.

Edit: also skate 2 is not the same as skate 3, this is coming from someone who has played all 3.

Mitch, your going to say that the MNR online is a complete wreck when the Skate 3 online is, in my opinion, the worst off all three. I love Skate 3 but the online Never works and when it does its laggy as sh!t

June 14, 2010 at 6:48 am #62581

mocte32
Member

both

June 14, 2010 at 7:32 am #62582

Miiiitch
Member

TomTom12992 said:

Miiiitch said:

Post edited 10:49 pm – 06/11/2010 by Miiiitch

I own both and while they both have there flaws Skate 3 is the much better game of the 2, MNR has the most ridiculous loading times I have ever seen (LBP never had this problem and there essentially the same game except LBP was platforming), the gameplay of MNR is not that smooth (especially online) and the online itself is a complete wreck. In the end it’s up to you and they are both enjoyable games but Skate 3 is definently better.

Edit: also skate 2 is not the same as skate 3, this is coming from someone who has played all 3.

Mitch, your going to say that the MNR online is a complete wreck when the Skate 3 online is, in my opinion, the worst off all three. I love Skate 3 but the online Never works and when it does its laggy as sh!t

That's because it's your opinion not mine mate, I have not really had any problems with the skate 3 online thus far.

June 14, 2010 at 2:05 pm #62584

MaDDoGG87
Member

mocte32 said:

both

if i was able to get both then i wouldn’t of posted the question..

i haven’t had any problems with MNR’s online & iv been playing xp races & splitscreen online & im glad i got MNR becausea couple of people on my friends list cant even connect to S3 online
Author

Posts